7th April 2020
Developmental leadership in a time of global pandemic
David Hudson, Claire Mcloughlin, Chris Roche, Alana Tomlin
The world has been turned upside down. The kaleidoscope has been shaken. We are all coming to terms with not only how our personal and working lives have changed, but how the world will alter over the coming weeks, months and years.
Leadership is more important than ever at critical junctures like this. And understanding when and how it can be a force for positive change is more vital than ever.
Few doubt this will be a turning point in history. But what happens during and after this crisis will not happen automatically, and it is not inevitable. How the world changes will be the outcome of the choices we make, as individuals and as a global society.
A myriad of everyday decisions are now being taken, sometimes for the greater good and sometimes self-serving, by people with power. By people who are either bestowed with, or who are claiming, the space to act.
The outcomes will not always be foreseen or intended. The complexity and globality of the pandemic and the dependencies within and between human societies means they will be radically non-linear. What is certain is that we will have to live with the institutional legacies of choices that are not obviously rational or desirable.
While the public gaze is mainly on our Presidents and Prime Ministers, leadership is being exercised everywhere: From the global coalition aiming to accelerate clinical research in resource-poor settings, to the youth leaders calling for national solidarity in the Solomon Islands.
These leaders cannot bring about change single-handedly. Leadership is about much more than motivated individuals: people need to overcome barriers to collective action, and often push up against social norms. Wherever they are working, the ability of leaders to make and enforce new rules, and how sustainable these decisions will be, will fundamentally rest on their legitimacy. How do leaders bring their followers with them? How are leaders and their decisions perceived and how does this vary across different cultures and contexts? Something that might work in China or South Korea will not in Venezuela or Kenya.
New leadership will also emerge through this crisis. Individuals will step forward and step up. An unprecedented level of co-ordination will be required on the part of international and local agencies. Regional co-operation will be stress-tested, and it will be up to individual leaders to decide how these institutions adapt.
How can leaders – wherever they are – learn to manoeuvre and build effective coalitions given politics is the art of the possible? We can learn by looking at innovation and strategies from across the world. Listening, curating, and understanding those stories, lessons, and insights is crucial right now.
DLP has been reflecting on what we – professionally, as a small research programme that occupies a niche in the international development ecosystem – can and should do. Our planned research projects, designed over the past year, aimed to carry out fieldwork across the Pacific and Asia through local and international research partnerships. But our research has been paused as we and our research partners reimagine how it might work; evolve, iterate and adapt. We are forced to pivot.
We are committed to building a practical and policy relevant evidence base, focussed on developmental leadership. We will keep working on our understanding of developmental leadership as a local, strategic, political, and collective process.
But the COVID-19 pandemic offers an opportunity to look at our four research questions through the lens of this crisis:
- How is leadership understood in different contexts? What do people want from leaders across different settings? How do leaders actively cultivate perceptions of their legitimacy? How do leaders navigate between different cultural expectations?
- Where do leaders come from? How do future leaders accrue and make use of resources? What are the various pathways in and through leadership? How does the identity, personality styles and traits of leaders inform the choices they make?
- How do leaders collectively influence development? What is the role of identity and intersectionality in collective action? How do collectives build internal and external legitimacy? How does collective action happen in contexts where civic space is shrinking? How do collectives change norms and ideas?
- How can developmental leadership be supported? What mix of support enhances leaders’ resources to expand their choices? How have successful programs navigated and adapted to promote developmental leadership? How do programs help shape the enabling environment for developmental leadership? How are development agencies adapting their own leadership, policies and business practices to support developmental leadership?
And here’s what we are planning to do to try to learn more about these questions through the world’s response to COVID-19:
Leadership stories. In moments like this – and indeed much of the time – practice runs ahead of research and evidence. We will look to amplify the voices of leaders, activists and coalitions. New, important spaces of leadership are opening up as the aid system transforms and the role of external actors is reconfigured. How are leaders and collectives adapting to the crisis? Where are the emerging futures in this ever-changing political environment? How are the relationships between states and societies being altered, and where will new institutions ‘stick’? What new forms of international cooperation and solidarity are emerging which facilitate the emergence of developmental leadership? We are especially interested in voices and spaces that are critical but often marginalised or hidden.
Leadership Observatory. In a new weekly feature, we will be collecting and summarising the top five or so resources – papers, articles, videos, podcasts, interviews or Twitter threads – for anyone interested in understanding better the challenges of leadership at the development-humanitarian nexus and / or how to support the processes of leadership. Each Observatory will be a five-minute read, providing a one-stop-shop of curated wisdom, for even the busiest of us to keep abreast of the most important thinking from around the globe.
Leadership evidence. Finally, while by definition, almost all of the evidence-base around leadership was developed before COVID-19, there are many lessons for leadership that are timeless, or lessons from other crisis situations comfortably translate to our current challenges. Previous epidemics and pandemics also provide insight about leadership, uncertainty and decision-making. Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it. We will be trawling the evidence-base from DLP and beyond to bring together the best evidence on how leadership can and does respond to crisis.
It has not been lost on us that we are well-placed to display leadership on leadership for development. But equally, we are all followers too, and effective leadership only happens together.
So, if you have a story about leadership and locally-led initiatives, or want to contribute to the conversation, please get in touch, or email us [email protected] We are particularly interested in giving a voice to people on the front line that might challenge assumptions and encourage a different way of thinking about those critical choices that are already shaping our post-COVID world.
Subscribe to the weekly #LeadershipObvs
Professor of Politics and Development, University of Birmingham, and Director, Developmental Leadership Program
Lecturer in Political Sociology, University of Birmingham, and Deputy Director (Research), Developmental Leadership Program
Professor of Development Practice and Director of the Institute of Human Security and Social Change, La Trobe University, and Deputy Director (Impact), Developmental Leadership Program
Program Manager and Deputy Director (Operations), Developmental Leadership Program, University of Birmingham