Political Engagement with Non-State Actors in Areas of Limited Statehood

Even where there are no functioning state structures, few societies remain ungoverned. Often non-state actors (NSAs) provide the goods, services and protections that the state may – for whatever reason – be unable to deliver to its citizens. NSAs include community-based and civil society groups, humanitarian and development organisations, armed actors and opposition groups, and the private sector and business interests, all working at various levels.

This paper surveys the literature on development and NSAs. It sets out the evidence for the merits of engaging politically with NSAs by incorporating them into governance and statebuilding programmes, and examines the challenges this may pose.

It can be difficult to define some actors that clearly have significant influence but no obvious formal governance role; and attempts to define NSAs beyond the basics of 'not a state, but exerting influence' tend to include normative judgements about whether this influence is positive or negative.

The paper finds that how practitioners engage with an NSA often depends on this type of normative judgement. They are also further handicapped by the fact that there is currently no coherent view in the development community about whether donors and practitioners should engage with such actors.

Yet the evidence suggests that truly inclusive and sustainable political settlements will need to involve any NSAs able to exercise significant economic, political, or social influence on the development process, regardless of whether this influence is positive or negative.

Download the full paper below (24pp, 600 KB), or just the Executive summary (2pp, 180 KB).

About DLP

The Developmental Leadership Program (DLP) is an international research initiative that explores how leadership, power and political processes drive or block successful development.

DLP focuses on the crucial role of home-grown leaderships and coalitions in forging legitimate political settlements and institutions that promote developmental outcomes, such as sustainable growth, political stability and inclusive social development.

Find out more

News

New studies on leadership for transformational change in Africa

Thursday 31st May 2018

A new series of studies asks what factors support or hinder leadership for transformational change in Africa. They are published in collaboration with the UONGOZI Institute.

Read more

New article on politically informed work for climate change mitigation in China and India

Monday 21st May 2018

In Development Policy Review, Tom Harrison and Genia Kostka draw on their DLP research project to explore 'Bureaucratic manoeuvres and the local politics of climate change mitigation in China and India'.

Read more

Follow: @dlprog